Building a Customer Service Scorecard: Best Practices for Success

In the current market, simply responding to or resolving support issues doesn’t lead to positive customer service experience worth winning their loyalty. Good customer service is now measured by the quality of support and your agents’ performance.

But how do you evaluate the effectiveness of your customer service? Make use of customer service scorecards to evaluate and provide valuable insight into the support quality and your support team’s strengths and weaknesses.

Effective scorecards help businesses identify areas for improvement, make necessary changes, and eventually enhance customer experience.

This blog will provide you with everything you need to know about customer service scorecards.

What is a customer service scorecard?

A customer service scorecard is a method that businesses use to measure and quantify the effectiveness of their customer service efforts.

It is a systematic framework for tracking and analyzing the performance of support agents and the overall quality of customer service.

These scorecards include a set of key performance indicators that align with the company’s objectives.

Insights from the scorecard enable companies to come up with solutions to improve their support teams’ performance and deliver high-quality customer service.

Reasons why businesses use customer support scorecards

Customers’ experience relies on how good the overall support is and how well the agents interact with them across all touchpoints.

The following are the benefits of using customer service scorecards:

Helps set clear customer service standards and goals

Measuring progress enables you to understand if your performance meets expectations or requires further improvements.

A customer service scorecard allows businesses to set measurable performance targets for their support team, such as SLA response or resolution times.

Setting goals and tracking metrics that directly contribute to these objectives can make support teams align customer service efforts to achieve them, such as increasing sales or improving brand image.

Provides a basis for improving the customer experience

Customer service scorecard helps monitor your customer experience metrics.

This enables you to quickly notice the instances when customers are not satisfied and take corrective measures to retain them.

According to SQM group statistics, 95% of customers can continue to do business with a company because they are very satisfied with the support team’s customer experience.

 Drives accountability

Tracking customer service scorecard metrics at the individual and team levels holds support agents accountable for their performance.

Knowing that their productivity can directly affect their overall evaluation makes agents be careful in identifying areas to refine in their support operations.

This motivates them to work even harder towards attaining excellent performance that can promote a culture of responsibility and an ongoing improvement within the team.

Provides insights into team’s performance

The scorecard organizes essential performance data in an easy-to-understand format, enabling team leads to track individual and team performance over time.

This allows them to understand whether or not their efficiency and productivity are up to standard.

Companies use the data to identify trends, delays, or repetitive issues and make informed decisions about allocating resources to different teams, training needs, and task management.

Identifies employee training gaps

Customer service scorecard metrics provide managers with the information they can use to identify agents’ skills gaps.

The data enables companies to invest in relevant training programs to improve employee performance and service quality.

Additionally, businesses can recognize inefficiencies, like low first response time, slow resolution time, or low satisfaction scores, which are then addressed to improve the overall quality of service.

Provides a competitive advantage

Customer service scorecard metrics provide companies with insights, enabling them to adapt to changes consistently.

The continuous improvement process helps businesses exceed customer expectations and gives them an upper hand over their competitors who may not have such a structured approach.

Additionally, holding customer service teams accountable and aligning their performance with business objectives can differentiate companies and create a stronger market position.

What should be included in a customer service scorecard?

Here is the most essential information to include in your scorecard so everybody works towards the same goal.

Review goals

Focusing on how well customer service teams meet targets and adjusting where necessary can improve the overall performance.

If a certain goal such as response time or resolution rate is consistently increasing, review to identify the cause and take corrective measures.

Conversely, if your team consistently exceeds certain set goals, you might decide to raise the bar to drive further growth.

For instance, if your team achieves 90% FCR continually, you can adjust to a higher target instead, say 95%.

Review period

The review period is the duration within which agents’ performance and support quality are evaluated.
It helps show when the review took place, revisits the previous reviews to track progress, and identifies possible improvements.
Keep the review lists precise so that you can review them daily, weekly, monthly, or quarterly, depending on the organization’s goals.

Reviewers and reviewees

Reviewers can be the managers and supervisors, whereas reviewees are the support teams or individual agents being evaluated.

List down all the participants in the rating process in your documentation for clear and transparent analysis.

Rating categories

Rating categories are the specific areas that are assessed to gauge the performance of your team.

For instance, you might decide to answer these questions while rating your agents:

• Are they using clear and correct grammar?
• Do they communicate in a friendly tone?
• Do the agents personalize interactions?
• Are they following company policies and procedures?
• Are they taking extra steps to fully meet customer expectations?

Having too many categories can overwhelm your customers, while having too few may not yield sufficient insight into your support operations and performance.

For example, on a scale of 1 to 5, a support agent who performed exceptionally may receive a 5, whereas an agent who needs improvements may score a 3.

Key performance metrics

Businesses can offer products and services to their clients but do not understand the overall experience delivered to customers.

Customer service scorecards usually entail performance metrics that help companies evaluate the efficiency and effectiveness of support being offered.

Category weights

Category weights is the value you wish to attain in each metric for you to achieve your target.

However, you have to prioritize certain areas over others based on their importance in regard to your desired goal.

Assign appropriate weights to each metric based on its role and your objective to ensure that critical metrics have more impact on the overall value.

For example, if you believe customer satisfaction has the most significant impact on customer loyalty, then you can assign it to the highest target score.

Feedback

Customer service scorecards should include space for constructive comments for reviewers to expand and provide context easily.

Well-structured feedback sessions help team members understand their scores, identify areas to refine, and develop their skills for better results.

How to build a customer service scorecard

Now that you know what your scorecard should include, here is a step-by-step guide on creating an effective customer service scorecard.

Utilize a customer service scorecard template

Consider using a customer service scorecard template with predefined fields to ensure you do not leave anything behind.

Customize the scorecard based on the goals of your customer support processes.

Additionally, organize the scorecard in an easy to understand and visually appealing layout so you can clearly feature the ratings.

Define your goals and objectives

Clearly outline your customer service objectives that you aim to achieve within a specified period with the scorecard.

Are you intending to improve customer satisfaction, reduce response times, enhance agent productivity, or increase customer retention?

Set targets and benchmarks for realistic performance based on historical data, company standards, and business objectives.

Consider involving your employees in any customer-facing roles in the process of setting the goals.

For example, if the average response time is 6 hours and you intend to reduce it, you can set a target of a shorter time, say 4 hours, over the next quarter.

Select the right customer service scorecard metrics

Choose metrics that can give a comprehensive overview of the quality of service and operational efficiency and align with your defined objectives and goals.

Include metrics that indicate the average duration of interactions, customer satisfaction, and agents’ effectiveness.

The following is a summary of the metrics to be included in the scorecard.

Collect and analyze data

Use post-interaction surveys to gather data from multiple customer service channels such as email, calls, live chat, social media, and in-person interactions to get data on customer satisfaction (CSAT), customer effort score (CES), or net promoter score (NPS), among other metrics.

Update your customer service scorecard results to ensure it is relevant to customer service trends and whether it is on track to achieve the set goals.

Track individual agents’ performance to identify strengths and weaknesses using agent-specific KPI such as average resolution time, etc. This helps you identify how each support agent is performing and areas to improve in.

Recognize the top performers to encourage them to keep up the good work and motivate the rest of your team to deliver the best support.

Implement a feedback mechanism

Share the scorecard results with your customer service team and adopt a feedback mechanism for them to give opinions and suggestions on how to improve.

Gallup conducted research and found that 26% of support agents agree that the feedback they get helps them to do their work in a better way.

Refine the customer support scorecard to adapt to changing business goals, new technologies, and evolving customer expectations.

Keep an eye on metrics related to new trends in customer service, such as artificial intelligence and omnichannel support, among others, to assist you in adjusting your scorecard.

Consider integrating artificial intelligence tools that can offer deeper insights into customer sentiment, predict future trends, or highlight emerging issues.

Customer service scorecard example

This customer service scorecard provides a clear overview of performance against set targets, enabling businesses to identify where improvements are required or where the team is exceeding performance.

The positive variances, like the NPS and customer retention rate, indicate that customers trust your brand and are likely to refer to others.

Nonetheless, there are several areas that require enhancement, such as addressing customer issues during the initial contact and enhancing the overall customer experience.

Leverage customer service scorecards for exceptional support experiences

Evaluating the overall team performance and the quality of support you offer can help you refine customer service strategies and enhance the team’s productivity.

Review and analyze your customer service scorecard data frequently to achieve customer service excellence and satisfaction.

If you have any additional insights into customer service scorecards, please share them in the comments section.

BoldDesk provides insightful data to help you update your customer service scorecard so you can manage your team better.

Contact us for a 30-minute live demo and discover how BoldDesk can enable you to stand out.

Sign up for a 15-day free trial to experience our capabilities.

FAQs

Why are customer service scorecards important for businesses?

Customer service scorecards provide insights into how well support agents meet customer needs and service quality goals.

What is the difference between a customer service scorecard and a QA scorecard?

Both customer service scorecards and QA scorecards are methods used to measure performance, but they focus on different aspects.

A customer service scorecard evaluates the effectiveness of support based on agent interactions, while a QA Scorecard focuses more on the company’s adherence to policies and compliance with standards.

How can a customer service scorecard improve performance?

Regularly reviewing scorecards enables businesses to identify support trends, recognize high performers, identify agents that are lacking in skills, and provide necessary resources or training for continuous improvement.

How often should customer service scorecards be updated?

Customer service scorecards should be updated regularly, depending on business needs. Scorecards can be reviewed frequently to closely monitor performance and address any concerns.

Related articles

• Top Customer Service Metrics to Measure and Track
• Customer Service Reports: Best Tips & Metrics to Track
• 10 Key Customer Satisfaction Metrics to Measure